Securities Lending | Learn to Manage the Risks

Introduction

Securities lending is the provision of collateralized loans to eligible borrowers by securities lenders. Collateral may be cash, a bank letter of credit, a certificate of deposit (CD), or securities as agreed in advance. At the end of every securities lending transaction, both parties involved must return the same amount of securities and collateral to each other.

Fees and Profitability

In a securities loan, the borrower pays the lender an agreed fee, an annualized percentage of the current market value of the securities loaned. This is typically processed monthly.

If the lender recalls security during the life of the loan, the borrower must return the security to the lender. This does not affect the agreed fee for the loan. Lenders review their portfolios regularly and may recall securities that are in high demand. If this happens, they can negotiate a higher cost with the borrower for the remainder of the loan.

On securities loans that are collateralized by cash, the lender pays the borrower a percentage of the interest gained on the cash investment. This percentage is likely below the market rate to enable the lender to reinvest the money at a higher rate in the market to make a profit

The History of Securities Lending

Past – the late 1800’s

Due to a lack of immediately available certificates for US railway bonds (sold by certain clients), brokers/dealers borrow certificates from other investors in order to complete the transactions.

At the current time Borrowing among brokers/dealers has expanded to include large institutional investors around the world lending and borrowing equities. Most governments here and abroad have given their blessing to such lending, which was suggested by the Group of Thirty (G30) as a tool for industry liquidity.

Present

Borrowing among brokers/dealers has expanded to include large institutional investors around the world lending and borrowing equities. Most governments here and abroad have given their blessing to such lending, which was suggested by the Group of Thirty (G30) as a tool for industry liquidity.

Common Reasons to Borrow Securities

Reasons to Borrow Securities

The reasons for securities lending are as follows:

  • Arbitrage is the term used to describe the act of taking advantage of price differences in different markets by simultaneously buying and selling the same security. Some arbitrage strategies include convertible bond arbitrage, index arbitrage, relative value arbitrage, and tax arbitrage.
  • A hedge is an investment position intended to offset potential losses or gains that a companion investment may incur. In simple language, a barrier reduces any substantial losses or gains suffered by an individual or an organization. A variety of complex financial instruments and strategies are used as hedges, including but not limited to futures contracts, options, and swaps.
  • A settlement fails when the delivering party cannot complete a securities transaction as contracted at the specified time and/or place.

Common Reasons to Lend Securities

Reasons to Lend Securities

  • The ability to make more money.
  • With securities lending service typically comes additional related businesses, such as custody, clearing, credit, foreign exchange, funds transfer, cash management, etc.
  • To avoid the loss of present and future lucrative business and relationships, you’ll need to employ a defensive strategy to balance competition.

Participants in Securities Lending

The following are examples of functional participants:

  • Agents: Firms that act as intermediaries between borrowers and lenders in creating and completing securities loans.
  • Borrowers: Companies that use borrowed securities for trading and/or operational purposes temporarily.
  • Finders: companies that link borrowers and lenders; 
  • A lender is a company that supplies securities for temporary loans to borrowers.

Some middlemen coordinate access between lenders and borrowers in the securities lending industry.

  • Custodian banks: These are the banks that lend securities to their participating institutional clients from the holdings in question.
  • Brokers that Specialize in Securities Lending: these brokers provide their clients (often hedge funds) access to the securities lending procedure.
  • Securities Clearing Houses and Centralized Securities Depositories are organizations that provide automated services, such as security identification and tracking: These organizations usually settle securities lending transactions through one of the large central depositories.

Amongst other services, intermediaries provide the following:

  • Providing liquidity (access to required securities on a timely basis)
  • Mark to market valuations (provided to both the lenders and borrowers);
  • Verifying the eligibility of related collateral;
  • Custody of the underlying securities;
  • Inter-account transfers;
  • Processing of related corporate actions;
  • Daily monitoring and reporting; and, 
  • Economies of scale allow participation on a more feasible basis than otherwise possible.

A tri-party agreement exists between lenders and borrowers who wish to formalize their participation through intermediaries. In these arrangements, it is typical for the borrower to pay custodian fees.

The significance of this is that most custodians can serve as agents by indemnifying borrowers against the complete return of loaned securities to lenders or the collection and payment of monetary compensation equal to the value of any protection at the time a default can occur.

Participants

Lendable Securities

Lendable domestic securities include:

  • Corporate bonds;
  • Equities;
  • U.S. Treasuries/agencies

Lendable international issues include:

  • Equities;
  • Eurobonds; 
  • Sovereigns.

Different Types of Collateral

Types of Collateral

Processing of Collateral Receipt

The simultaneous exchange of securities and collateral is known as domestic processing.

International processing requires that the collateral be received FIRST (usually 24 hours in advance) BEFORE the securities to be loaned are delivered.

Processing Securities Delivery

Domestic loans can be delivered in several ways: DTCC, Federal Reserve Bank, NSCC, other clearing corporations or securities depositories, and physical.

Euroclear, Clearstream (CEDEL), other national clearing companies or securities depositories, and physical are the main ways that Eurobonds are distributed.

Risks of Joining

Risks

Failure to establish securities lending services per schedule, content, quality of performance, financial outcomes, and other criteria may result in the loss of money invested in developing the business and related securities.

The following are a few examples of monetary damage: through a clerical error, failure to execute precisely, and other unforeseen circumstances.

Risk Management

Types of Risks

Borrower Default Risk

The potential for a borrower not repaying their debt could lead to the loss of financial assets by the lending party. This risk is managed through:

  • Maintenance of updated risk management standards and safeguards; 
  • Dedicated industry credit assessments;
  • Qualitative/quantitative analysis;
  • Selective use of acceptable borrowers;
  • Limits are carefully set for each borrower;
  • Diversification of types of borrowers;
  • Confirmed receipt of collateral prior to delivery of securities;
  • Maintenance of required collateral margins; and more.

Managing Risks

Loss Risk Associated With Collateral

Several risks are associated with collateral, including the risk of loss. This refers to the loss of financial assets caused by the failure to access and use related collateral to sufficiently replace the value of the securities, which are not returned in part or full when required. Central banks manage such risks through various methods, including setting minimum reserve requirements and cuts and monitoring and managing collateral availability.

  • Maintenance of updated risk management standards and safeguards; 
  • Acceptance and use of high-quality collateral;
  • Proper possession and control of all related collateral; and, 
  • Daily mark-to-market and maintenance of proper, timely collateral margins. 

Agent Default Risk

The risk of agent default refers to the loss of financial assets that could occur if an agent fails to perform their duties. This type of risk can be managed through measures such as:

  • Keep security standards and risk management up-to-date.
  • Use and maintenance of agreements that are properly documented.
  • Ensuring that all agents maintain accurate and up-to-date records of their collateral.
  • Monitoring and reviewing agents’ performance on a regular basis.

Employee Fraud Risk

The risks of employee fraud or error happening are referred to as “loss of financial assets.” This could be caused by something like an employee making a mistake, not doing their job properly, or trying to defraud the company. There are measures in place to help reduce these types of risks, which include:

  • Make sure that risk management guidelines and protections are up-to-date;
  • The right way to pre-screen employees
  • A continuously updated curriculum of technical courses; and,
  • To survive, your employees must be able to trust you.

Critical Issues

Each security has its own rules, processes, related dangers, and financial gains.

Long-term investors, such as pension funds, endowments, foundations, insurance companies, and mutual fund management firms, typically act as lenders in the securities market. These entities are motivated to supply securities by fee income generation and the potential for limited downside risk.

A corporate or individual client who is seeking to borrow stocks, bonds, precious metals, other commodities, or any combination of items. The borrower might be a broker/dealer in need of securities for an investment strategy (such as covering a short position) or operational reasons (such as avoiding a fail-to-deliver).

The agent, typically a commercial bank with expansive custodial abilities, provides two vital services:

  • Custody and securities processing, as well as asset servicing of the lendable assets, are all handled by custody banks.
  • The entire arrangement of the securities loans’ terms and conditions.

The agent may also help the lender by financially covering certain losses if the borrower does not return the securities they borrowed.

Since the Federal Reserve implemented the “Risk-Based Capital Guidelines” in January 1991, banks providing indemnifications to securities lending clients must set aside a portion of capital against such indemnifications.

The automatic stay of proceedings against a person’s assets, including the assets in possession of the person’s creditors, is an important issue in terms of securities loans.

Negotiation

“Negotiation” refers to the discussion and arrangement of viable securities loans. The following are elements of the negotiation procedure:

Securities involved – what, how much; 

Delivery details – where, when, how; 

Collateral – what form, amount, and timing; and, 

Rebate amount – how much is it, and what percentage? 

Guidelines for Investing in Collateral

In addition, the collateral investment must be under pre-determined standards. Collateral of superior quality should be invested, such as:

  • The United States Government offers securities that are either guaranteed or issued through its agencies and instrumentalities.
  • Time deposits and bankers acceptances: the U.S. and non-U.S. commercial banks Standard & Poors ratings of A1 or better;
  • Commercial paper or master demand notes: issued by entities in the U.S. and abroad, and which are given one of the two highest ratings by one of the four nationally recognized rating services – Duff and Phelps, Fitch Investors Service, Moody’s Investors Service, and Standard & Poors;
  • Repurchase transactions (REPOs). These are contracts to acquire a government or agency security at a set price and duration, with the option to sell it back to the same entity at a higher rate in order to repay for the use of the money.
  • Floating and fluctuating demand notes, including those with maturities of less than one year whose interest is adjusted on a periodic basis based on specific short-term interest rates (obligations with maturities less than one year).

Marks to the Market

A “mark to the market” is a mathematical calculation performed by the lender to see whether collateral currently has enough value to repay borrowed assets (if the borrower does not return them.)

To protect against any unforeseen declines in the collateral’s market value, a margin of 2% to 5% is generally kept on top. If the collateral’s value falls below acceptable levels, the lender instructs the borrower to make up the difference immediately by providing extra collateral as needed.

Daily Pricing

The present market value is constantly tracked, including currency fluctuations for international loans.

For domestic loans, 102 percent margins must be maintained on the collateral (2% above current market value to cover the potential decrease in the market value of underlying collateral).

For loans outside of your home country, you must have collateral worth 105% more than the loan in order to cover any potential losses from market value changes.

Canceling Securities Loans

Securities loans are loaned securities and underlying collateral that are exchanged simultaneously, while they are not in the case of foreign equities.

The borrower’s securities are returned first, typically 24 hours ahead of time, before the lender gets access to the collateral.

Revenue Sharing

Revenue-sharing in securities lending is calculated utilizing the following information from the securities loan:

Customers may be asked to pay a flat percentage of net income or, in some cases, give their whole earnings.

The borrower’s specific rebate is calculated by each of the securities loans related to them.

The securities lending agent subtracts all expenses from total profits together in both a detailed and summarized way.

Conclusion

In order to make a securities loan, you must have an understanding of the market, the securities being loaned, and the collateral being posted. You should also be aware of the various risks associated with securities lending.

Revenue sharing is an important aspect of securities lending, and you should be familiar with how it works before entering into any agreements.

Securities lending is the act of loaning out securities in exchange for collateral. The practice enables investors to generate income from idle securities, while also providing borrowers with the ability to use securities without having to purchase them outright.

Securities lending is the act of loaning out securities in exchange for collateral. The practice enables investors to generate income from idle securities, while also providing borrowers with the ability to use securities without having to purchase them outright.
There are a number of risks associated with securities lending, including the risk of market value changes, the risk of counterparty default, and the risk of collateral value changes.
Revenue sharing is an important aspect of securities lending, and you should be familiar with how it works before entering into any agreements. Revenue sharing is calculated utilizing the following information from the securities loan: the borrower's specific rebate is calculated by each of the securities loans related to them. The securities lending agent subtracts all expenses from total profits together in both a detailed and summarized way.
For domestic loans, 102 percent margins must be maintained on the collateral (2% above current market value to cover the potential decrease in the market value of underlying collateral). For loans outside of your home country, you must have collateral worth 105% more than the loan in order to cover any potential losses from market value changes.
Daily pricing is the process of tracking the present market value of a security loan, including currency fluctuations for international loans. For example, if a domestic U.S. loan has a market value of $100 at the time it is made, but the market value of the security falls to $90 by the end of the day, the borrower must provide additional collateral of $10 to cover the loss in value.

True Tamplin, BSc, CEPF®

About the Author
True Tamplin, BSc, CEPF®

True Tamplin is a published author, public speaker, CEO of UpDigital, and founder of Finance Strategists.

True is a Certified Educator in Personal Finance (CEPF®), author of The Handy Financial Ratios Guide, a member of the Society for Advancing Business Editing and Writing, contributes to his financial education site, Finance Strategists, and has spoken to various financial communities such as the CFA Institute, as well as university students like his Alma mater, Biola University, where he received a bachelor of science in business and data analytics.

To learn more about True, visit his personal website, view his author profile on Amazon, or check out his speaker profile on the CFA Institute website.